Cedar siding work on a Portland house is mostly about three things: using heartwood where the wall stays wet, keeping every face of every board sealed, and renewing the finish before the wood goes grey. Western red cedar is a good siding wood for this climate, but the USDA Wood Handbook is specific about why. Its heartwood is rated resistant to decay; its sapwood, like the sapwood of essentially every species, is not. Where the finish fails and the end grain stays wet through a Portland winter, cedar rots too.
To price cedar repair or replacement, request a siding quote and note where boards are greying, soft or wet at the ends.
Clear or knotty: cedar siding grades
The Western Red Cedar Lumber Association grades cedar siding in two families (WRCLA grades):
- Clear grades are chosen for a face free of knots. Clear V.G. Heart is sawn vertical grain (edge grain), kiln dried, with a heartwood face free from growth characteristics. Clear Heart has heartwood on the exposed face. A Clear is mixed grain and allows a few more characteristics, and is commonly sold as “A and Better” with a share of B Clear.
- Knotty grades keep the knots as part of the look. In Select Knotty the knots are sound and tight; Architect Knotty has no open characteristics or through defects.
Two practical points follow for a Portland house. On a wet or shaded wall, a heartwood-face grade is the better buy, because the Wood Handbook ties cedar’s decay resistance to the heartwood. And on a repair, the new boards should match the existing grade as well as the profile, or the patch shows once the stain goes on.
Cedar shingle siding and cedar shake siding
Cedar shingle siding and cedar shake siding are both sold in grades, and a repair should match the grade as well as the size. Cedar shingles are graded by the Cedar Shake & Shingle Bureau. No. 1 Blue Label is its highest grade for roofs and sidewalls: all heartwood, all clear and all edge grain. No. 2 Red Label has a clear portion of at least 10 inches on a 16-inch shingle, and allows flat grain and limited sapwood. No. 3 Black Label is a utility grade for economy work and secondary buildings. Shingles come in 16-, 18- and 24-inch lengths, sold as Fivex, Perfection and Royal. Gables on older Portland houses are often shingled, and a gable repair should name the grade and length it is matching. Shakes, split rather than sawn, are harder to match by texture; the table above sets out the difference.
Why cedar fails on a Portland house
- Finish failure. Once stain or paint wears through, cedar greys, checks and cups, and water soaks into the cracks.
- Wet end grain. Board ends at butt joints, corners and window trim absorb water fastest; rot usually starts there. See dry rot in siding, and what dry rot is and where it starts on a Portland house.
- Ground and deck contact. The WRCLA asks for siding at least 6 inches off the ground. Boards buried in bark mulch or sitting on a deck stay wet regardless of grade.
- Wrong nails. Plain steel reacts with cedar’s natural oils and streaks the wall. Hot-dipped galvanized, aluminum or stainless nails avoid it, and stainless is the WRCLA’s first choice under a transparent stain.
- Moisture trapped behind the boards. The WRCLA notes that rigid foam sheathing can make moisture collect on the back of the siding, and recommends nailing to furring strips where an air space is wanted, so the back of the boards can vent. The insulated siding guide covers what adding foam changes on a re-side.
Cedar siding styles
- Bevel (clapboard) siding. Tapered boards lapped over each other, the most common cedar siding on older Portland houses.
- Tongue-and-groove and channel siding. Flat-faced boards laid horizontally or vertically, common on mid-century houses.
- Board-and-batten. Wide vertical boards with narrow battens over the joints; the board and batten guide covers how it is nailed and flashed.
- Shingles. Sawn cedar shingles in straight, staggered or decorative courses, often in gables.
Repairing cedar board by board
A cedar repair replaces only what is damaged: the contractor probes suspect boards, cuts out the soft ones, and weaves in new cedar with the joints staggered. The WRCLA recommends buying boards pre-primed or pre-finished, applying finish to all six sides, and priming or staining every end cut made on site. Where the original boards are a profile or width no longer stocked, or the house is in a historic district, the job moves into historic wood siding repair, where saving and matching old boards is the main skill.
Keeping the finish ahead of the rain
Cedar’s life on a Portland wall comes down to its finish. The USDA Wood Handbook’s figures run from a few years for a semitransparent stain on smooth boards to 15 to 20 years for primer and two top-coats of paint on saw-textured cedar, and it notes that a single top-coat cuts the life of paint to about half. Saw-textured faces hold a finish noticeably longer than smooth ones. How long siding lasts sets out the full table. Finish when the wood is dry: the Handbook warns that painting wood wetter than 20 percent moisture invites blistering and peeling, which in Portland points to July and August.
Cedar, or something that looks like it?
When a cedar wall is past repair, the options are new cedar, fiber cement lap or shingles with a wood-grain texture (fiber cement siding), or engineered wood. Fiber cement does not rot and needs less finish work; cedar is lighter, repairable board by board, and the only one of the three that is actually wood. In Portland’s Conservation Districts, the design standards allow wood shingles but not shakes, and in historic districts generally review may decide the material for you: see the Portland page.
Cedar siding prices
HomeGuide’s national guide puts installed cedar siding at $6 to $16 per sq ft of wall, national, with bevel boards toward the low end and shingles and clear grades toward the high end; the row below gives the source and the date it was checked. A cedar repair is priced as a repair visit instead, against Angi’s Portland range of $903 to $2,835 per job. The siding cost page explains what else goes into a quote, and the siding inspection checklist shows what to look at on a cedar wall each year before the rains.
Last updated