Siding work on a Portland-area house falls into six kinds of job. Two are about scope: repairing part of a wall, or replacing the siding on the whole house. Three are about material: fiber cement, vinyl and cedar each have their own install rules and failure patterns. The sixth, historic wood siding repair, exists because original wood siding on older Portland houses is often worth saving and, in historic districts, is often the only option that avoids a review.
Repair or full replacement?
Siding repair is targeted work: cutting out rotted or swollen boards and weaving in matching ones, rebuilding the flashing where a leak shows, closing up storm damage, and working out why paint keeps failing on the same boards. It fits when the damage is confined to one wall or a few boards, the sheathing behind is sound, and the siding is still made or can be matched.
Siding replacement takes the cladding off down to the sheathing, repairs whatever the old siding was hiding, and rebuilds the wall’s weather layers before the new siding goes on: water-resistive barrier, flashed windows and doors, kickouts at roof edges, and a drainage gap where the code calls for one. It fits when the same failure shows on several walls, when the product is one that fails everywhere at once, such as hardboard or T1-11, or when repairs keep finding soft sheathing.
The problems guide matches common symptoms to one or the other.
The material pages
Fiber cement, most often James Hardie’s, comes as lap boards, 4-by-8 panels, shingles and trim. It does not rot, but it is heavy, it gives off silica dust when cut, and the maker’s clearances to the ground and to roofing decide how well it lasts. It is a common replacement for failed hardboard and T1-11.
Vinyl siding has the lowest starting price per square foot of the four materials compared below, and never needs paint. It lasts when it hangs loosely enough to move with temperature; nailed tight, it ripples on the first hot afternoon. Historic districts often turn it down over original wood.
Cedar siding covers bevel, channel and board-and-batten boards and sawn shingles. It needs its stain or paint kept up and its bottom edge kept clear of soil and decks, and it takes corrosion-resistant nails. It is the usual like-for-like choice on older houses.
Engineered wood, such as LP SmartSide, is made of resin-treated wood strands, lighter than fiber cement, and its cut ends and nail heads need sealing per the maker’s instructions. It is installed as part of a siding replacement; the LP SmartSide guide covers the product, its install rules and warranty, and how it compares with fiber cement or LP SmartSide’s older namesake.
Historic wood siding repair
Historic wood siding repair keeps original boards in place: consolidating and filling soft wood with epoxy, splicing in Dutchman patches, replacing only the boards that are past saving with wood milled to the same profile, and working lead-safe. In Portland’s City Historic and Conservation Districts, replacing siding needs historic resource review even when new wood replaces old, while repairing the existing material is exempt, so repair is often the practical route there. Oregon City’s Historic Review Board has its own written siding policies.
What every siding job has in common
Whatever the material, the same few things decide whether new siding lasts:
- Clearance at the bottom. Siding that sits in soil, mulch or on a patio stays wet. Fiber cement’s maker asks for 6 inches to finished ground.
- Flashing at every opening and roof edge. Most hidden water damage starts at a window without head flashing or a roof edge without a kickout.
- A drainage path. Oregon’s residential code wants a water-resistive barrier behind the siding and, by default, a gap of at least 1/8 inch so water can run out.
- Lead-safe work on pre-1978 houses. Past Oregon’s minor-repair limit of disturbed exterior paint, the contractor needs the CCB’s Lead-Based Paint Renovation license.
- Permits only where they apply. Oregon exempts siding that does not have to be fire-rated; walls less than 3 feet from a property line do.
What type of siding is best for Portland, Oregon?
No one material wins on every house. Portland’s weather sets the test: NOAA’s 1991-2020 normals give the airport about 37 inches of precipitation a year, more than five inches in each of November, December and January and about half an inch in each of July and August. Whatever goes on has to shed months of rain and let what gets behind it drain out. So the choice turns on a few questions about the house:
- Is it in a historic or conservation district, or is the siding original wood? Then repair, or like-for-like wood, is usually the route. Replacement needs review in Portland’s City districts, and vinyl over historic wood is often refused.
- What is failing now? Swollen hardboard and delaminating T1-11 are usually replaced with fiber cement or engineered wood, both of which come in lap and panel profiles.
- How close is the siding to soil, decks and roofing? Fiber cement and engineered wood each have maker clearances; walls that cannot meet them need the grade or the trim changed, or a different detail.
- How much upkeep will you do? Cedar needs its stain or paint kept up; primed boards need paint; vinyl needs none but must hang loose, and Portland reached 116°F on June 28, 2021.
- What is behind it? On any material, the code’s water-resistive barrier and drainage gap matter as much as the cladding.
The table below sets the four main materials side by side.
How the prices below work
The installed prices in the table are published ranges from named cost guides, each checked on the date shown. The fiber cement row is for Portland; the others are national figures and are listed as such. None of them is a quote. The siding cost page has every published figure, including tear-off, repair and regional whole-job averages, and explains what moves a job up or down the range. The contractor who looks at your walls gives the only number that applies to your house.
Last updated