Masonite siding replacement in Portland, Oregon is one of the most common re-side jobs on houses built or re-sided in the 1980s and 1990s. Hardboard lap siding, much of it sold under the Masonite name, and LP Inner-Seal OSB siding were both widely installed in those years, and both fail the same way: water gets past the paint at cut edges and nail holes, the wood fibers swell, and the lower edges of the boards flare out and soften.
Lake Oswego’s median home was built in 1982 and Gresham’s in 1981 (Census ACS 2020-2024), which puts a large share of both cities’ houses in that era. See the Lake Oswego and Gresham pages.
To price hardboard replacement on your own house, request a siding quote and mention roughly when the house was sided; hardboard was common on houses sided in the 1980s and 1990s.
Hardboard, OSB, wood or fiber cement? Four checks
- Look at an exposed edge. Hardboard has a dense, brown, papery fiber core with no grain; LP OSB shows flat wood strands pressed together.
- Check the texture. Hardboard lap usually has an embossed wood-grain pattern that repeats more regularly than real cedar.
- Check the date. A house sided between about 1980 and the late 1990s is a candidate.
- Look for a stamp. Board backs, visible in an attic or unfinished garage, sometimes carry the maker’s name.
If you cannot tell, a contractor can identify it in a few minutes.
Is there any settlement money left?
No. The class-action settlements covering Masonite hardboard siding and LP Inner-Seal OSB siding have closed to claims. If you are buying a house with this siding, it is worth pricing its replacement into the purchase.
Swapping boards vs. a whole-house re-side
A few swollen boards on one wall, with the rest in good shape and well painted, can be swapped out. Hardboard itself is mostly no longer made in the original profiles, so the replacements are fiber cement or engineered wood cut to match the exposure, then painted. If the boards turn out to be fiber cement already, the guide to fiber cement repair covers patching and replacing them. When swelling shows on most walls, siding replacement is the durable fix, and it lets the contractor check and repair the sheathing and add proper flashing and wrap.
Replacement materials for Masonite-era houses
- Fiber cement lap siding is the most common choice, because it will not swell or rot. Window and door trim often has to be built out for its extra thickness.
- Vinyl siding costs less and needs no paint.
- Engineered wood lap siding such as LP SmartSide is the product line that followed the older OSB sidings, with resin and treatments designed to resist moisture, and should be installed and sealed exactly to the maker’s instructions. Today’s LP SmartSide is a different product from the LP Inner-Seal siding covered by the old settlement; the LP SmartSide guide explains the difference.
Common finds under old hardboard
Expect some sheathing repair below windows and at the bottom of walls, missing or torn building paper, and windows set with little flashing. Ask for the quote to price sheathing replacement per sheet, so the surprise is a known unit cost. A house carrying 1980s or 1990s hardboard was built before 2004, so Oregon DEQ’s asbestos survey applies before the old siding comes off, and on a house that was re-sided in hardboard over an older layer, that layer is part of what the survey checks; the asbestos siding guide explains the rule. Related failures: water behind siding and T1-11 damage.
Budgeting for a hardboard re-side
The siding cost page lists regional averages for a full fiber cement or vinyl re-side and per-square-foot installed ranges for each material, each with its source and date, plus tear-off and disposal. As reference points, Angi’s Portland figure for installed fiber cement is $9 to $16 per sq ft of wall, Portland, HomeGuide’s national figure for engineered wood is $7 to $12 per sq ft of wall, national, and tearing off the old hardboard adds $70 to $200 per square (100 sq ft of wall), national.
Last updated