Materials

LP SmartSide Siding in Portland: Engineered Wood vs Hardie

LP SmartSide engineered wood siding on Portland homes: how it differs from 1990s LP siding, its install and warranty rules, and how it compares to Hardie.

LP SmartSide siding in Portland shows up in two places: on newer houses that were built with it, and in re-side quotes as the main alternative to fiber cement. It is engineered wood, made by LP Building Solutions, and it has to be installed and painted to LP’s rules to last, and to keep its warranty. This guide covers what it is, how it differs from the LP siding that failed in the 1990s, the installation details that matter in Portland’s rain, what the warranty says, and how it compares with James Hardie fiber cement. The documents behind it were read at source on October 4, 2026.

What LP SmartSide is

LP SmartSide is made from wood strands bonded with resin into boards and panels. LP’s frequently asked questions bulletin (revised September 9, 2024) describes the treatment it calls SmartGuard: binders, waxes and zinc borate through the core, and a water-resistant, resin-saturated paper overlay on the face. The independent code report for the product, ICC-ES ESR-1301, calls it treated engineered wood siding with a zinc borate preservative and factory-sealed edges.

LP itself makes the comparison people ask about: SmartSide uses the same kind of engineered wood strands as OSB sheathing for strength and stiffness. What separates it from a sheet of OSB is the treatment and the overlay. Since 2020, when LP sold its fiber-based siding plant and brand, SmartSide has been a strand product only.

Not the LP siding of the 1990s

The name causes confusion on Portland-area houses from the 1980s and 1990s. LP’s earlier product, OSB Inner-Seal lap siding, was the subject of a nationwide class settlement approved by the federal court in Oregon in 1996. It covered Inner-Seal siding installed before January 1, 1996, and the claims deadline, January 1, 2003, passed long ago (LP’s 1997 SEC filing). LP launched SmartSide in 1997, after that settlement.

Swollen, mushroomed lap boards on a house of that age are far more likely to be Inner-Seal or hardboard than SmartSide; hardboard siding failure covers how to tell them apart and what replaces them.

Profiles and finishes

LP’s warranty lists the SmartSide range: lap siding, panel siding, vertical siding, NickelGap, cedar-look shakes, trim and fascia, and soffit. Lap siding comes in 38 and 76 Series; panel siding in 38, 76 and 190 Series. Panels are 4 feet wide, so they can stand in for T1-11 on a house or addition that was built with T1-11 panels. Two panel variants, SmartFinish and SilverTech, are made for sheds and other accessory buildings and are not for houses.

Most SmartSide is sold primed and painted on site. ExpertFinish boards arrive factory-painted with a 100 percent acrylic finish, which takes the paint schedule out of a wet Portland spring but limits the color to LP’s range.

Install rules that matter in Portland’s rain

SmartSide’s failures, like fiber cement’s, come mostly from the places water reaches the edges. LP’s current lap siding instructions (form LPZB0515, December 8, 2023) and panel siding instructions (LPZB0512, April 26, 2024) set the rules a contractor should follow and a homeowner can check:

  • 6 inches to finished grade. No soil, bark mulch or pavers against the bottom course.
  • 1 inch above roofing where a wall meets a roof, with step flashing on the roof-to-wall line and a kickout flashing where a roof eave meets the wall.
  • 1 inch above porches, patios and walkways, reducible only where the surface drains and is under a roof.
  • A 3/16-inch gap at trim, sealed with a sealant meeting ASTM C920, Class 25 or better.
  • Every cut edge sealed. LP’s instruction is to seal all exposed cuts of siding and trim.
  • Nails snug, not overdriven. Hot-dip galvanized nails of at least 0.092-inch shank, heads seated snug to the face without distorting it; a heavier 0.113-inch nail may be required for higher wind loads. Countersunk counts as overdriven.
  • A water-resistive barrier behind it, which Oregon’s residential code also requires behind exterior siding.
  • Paint within 180 days, with 100 percent acrylic or oil-based paint. Stain and vinyl-based paints are not allowed on SmartSide.

In a Portland winter, the gap above a patio and the sealed cut ends at window trim are where problems show first. The Happy Valley page goes through how those clearances get lost on newer houses after move-in, and the Hillsboro page works through re-siding a 1990s house with failing OSB lap.

What the warranty covers

LP’s SmartSide limited warranty (form LPZB0523, for products bought from August 1, 2025) runs 50 years, prorated:

  • Years 1 to 5: labor and material for covered failures.
  • Years 6 to 50: material only, reduced by 2.22 percent a year.
  • Who it covers: the original purchaser and building owner, and the next owner. It cannot be passed on beyond that.
  • Conditions: the product has to be stored, installed, finished and maintained in line with LP’s instructions, and siding not installed by a licensed contractor is excluded. A problem has to be reported to LP within 30 days of discovery and before repairs start.

The ExpertFinish warranty adds a 15-year finish warranty: full coverage for five years, then 10 percent less each year. A house sided before August 2025 is covered by whichever version applied when the product was bought, so ask the builder or the original contractor for it.

In Oregon, “a licensed contractor” means one licensed by the Construction Contractors Board, and the guide to comparing siding quotes explains how to check one.

LP SmartSide vs James Hardie

Both are common choices for a Portland re-side, and both are installed over a water-resistive barrier with flashed openings. Where they differ:

LP SmartSide (engineered wood) James Hardie (fiber cement)
Material Treated wood strands with a resin-saturated overlay Cement, sand and cellulose fiber
Rot Wood, protected by treatment, overlay, sealed edges and paint Does not rot
Fire Combustible Noncombustible
Weight and cutting LP says it is lighter than fiber cement and cuts with common woodworking tools Heavier; it contains crystalline silica, so OSHA’s rule calls for saws with dust collection
Ground clearance 6 inches 6 inches
Primed boards Paint within 180 days Paint within 180 days
Substrate warranty 50 years, prorated after year 5; original owner and the next 30 years, non-prorated, transferable
Factory finish ExpertFinish, 15-year finish warranty ColorPlus, 15-year finish warranty

The Hardie terms come from James Hardie’s warranty page and the silica rule from OSHA’s construction standard. Fiber cement’s own install rules and downsides are on the fiber cement siding page.

Fiber cement’s case is strongest where a wall stays wet or fire resistance matters; SmartSide’s where weight, handling or the look and feel of wood matter more. In either case the details at the edges decide more than the brand does.

What LP SmartSide costs

HomeGuide’s national cost guide puts installed engineered wood siding such as LP SmartSide at $7 to $12 per sq ft of wall, national, checked September 27, 2026. For 1,000 square feet of wall, that is $7,000 to $12,000. Tear-off of the old siding, any sheathing repair, trim and paint are priced on top. Siding is priced by wall area, not the floor area of the house, which the siding cost page explains alongside every other material’s figures. For the whole job, see siding replacement, and for how long each material’s warranty and finish last, how long siding lasts.

Start My Siding Quote

No cost and no obligation. Tell us about the house and the siding problem to get started.

Questions, answered

Common questions

What is the downside of LP siding?

LP SmartSide is wood, treated and overlaid, so its weak points are the places water can reach bare wood: cut edges that were not sealed, nails driven too deep, boards too close to the ground, roofing or a patio, and primed boards left unpainted. LP's instructions require all of those to be done right, and its warranty depends on it. It is also not noncombustible the way fiber cement is, and the warranty is prorated after year five and covers only the original owner and the next one.

Is LP SmartSide just OSB?

Not in LP's description. LP says SmartSide and its OSB sheathing both use engineered wood strands for strength and stiffness, but SmartSide is treated through the core with binders, waxes and zinc borate and faced with a resin-saturated paper overlay, a combination LP calls the SmartGuard process. The ICC-ES code report for it, ESR-1301, describes a mat-formed wood substrate treated with zinc borate, with factory-sealed edges.

What is the average lifespan of LP SmartSide siding?

LP does not publish a lifespan beyond its warranty, which runs 50 years on a prorated basis. The two commonly cited lifespan sources give engineered wood siding the lifetime of the house (NAHB, 2007) and 100 years or more (InterNACHI); neither measured Portland houses. In practice the paint and the details at its edges decide how long a SmartSide wall lasts.

What's more expensive, LP or Hardie?

In the published ranges on this site, engineered wood such as LP SmartSide comes in at $7 to $12 per square foot installed (HomeGuide, national) and fiber cement at $9 to $16 per square foot of wall (Angi, Portland). The two figures come from different sources and areas, so compare written quotes for your own walls before deciding on price.

How much is LP smart siding per sq ft?

HomeGuide's national cost guide puts installed engineered wood siding such as LP SmartSide at $7 to $12 per sq ft of wall, national. For 1,000 square feet of wall that is $7,000 to $12,000, before tear-off of the old siding, sheathing repair, trim and paint. No source this site uses publishes a Portland-only figure for it.

A free siding quote request

Start My Siding Quote

No cost and no obligation. Tell us about the house and the siding problem to get started.

No cost to submit a request, and no obligation.