Re-siding

Stucco to Siding in Portland: Replacing Stucco and EIFS

Replacing stucco or EIFS with siding on a Portland house: telling the two apart, what removal uncovers, Oregon's code and EIFS law, permits and costs.

Replacing stucco with siding on a Portland house means taking the stucco off down to the sheathing, repairing whatever water has done behind it, and building a new wall to Oregon’s code: a water-resistive barrier, a drainage space, flashing at every opening, then the siding. The first question is whether the wall is traditional stucco at all, or EIFS.

This guide is about replacing stucco or EIFS. Patching cracks and holes in stucco is plaster work, a different trade, and is not covered here. Oregon moved to a new residential code on October 1, 2026, but plans drawn to the 2023 edition must still be accepted until March 31, 2027 (OAR 918-480-0005). The sections cited below are from the 2023 edition, and the sources were checked on October 7, 2026.

Stucco or EIFS: which do you have?

Building Science Corporation’s digest on the subject, BSD-146, puts it plainly: the two claddings can look the same and perform very differently. Traditional stucco is portland cement or lime bonded with sand. On a wood-frame Oregon house it goes on in three coats over metal or wire lath (2023 ORSC R703.7.2), at least 7/8 inch thick over wire lath (Table R702.1(1)). EIFS, the exterior insulation and finish system some people call synthetic stucco, is foam board, polystyrene or polyisocyanurate, glued or fastened to the wall, with glass-fiber mesh set in a base coat and a textured finish over it (ASTM E2568).

Traditional stucco Barrier EIFS EIFS with drainage
Under the finish Cement and sand plaster on wire or metal lath Foam insulation board Foam insulation board
Behind it Building paper: two layers, or an equivalent, over wood sheathing Bonded to the wall, with no drainage path A water-resistive barrier, with a way for water to drain
How it handles water Cracks let water in; the paper and a weep screed at the base drain it Relies on the face and its sealant joints Drains water that gets past the face
In Oregon today Still in the residential code (R703.7) Barred to licensed contractors except to repair or replace an existing system (ORS 701.555) The only EIFS in the residential code (R703.9)

The table draws on BSD-146, the code sections cited and the EIFS Industry Members Association, whose definition follows the model codes and ASTM.

From the sidewalk, the three are hard to tell apart. Where the finish has been cut or broken, at a dryer vent, a light fixture or a damaged corner, EIFS shows foam board under a thin coating, and stucco shows hard plaster with wire mesh in it. HUD’s Residential Rehabilitation Inspection Guide advises having a trained specialist check existing EIFS for concealed water damage and rot.

Why barrier EIFS on wood framing leaked

EIFS became popular in the 1980s and, in Building Science Corporation’s account, had a significant number of serious failures, almost all from rain getting in. Early systems were face-sealed: the outer coating and its sealant joints were meant to stop all the water, with no way out for any that got past. Water gets past anyway, mostly at joints and penetrations such as windows, railings and vents, and behind a face-sealed system it sits against wood that does not tolerate it (BSD-146). HUD’s 2000 inspection guide said most residential EIFS then in place was the non-draining kind over wood framing, with leaks and rotted framing a serious problem in many houses, especially at windows and doors.

Oregon answered in two ways. A state law passed in 2007 bars contractors licensed by the Construction Contractors Board from installing barrier-type EIFS on a new building, or on an existing one except to repair or replace a barrier system already there; it exempts architectural features that do not protect an interior space, and concrete or concrete-block walls (ORS 701.555). And the state residential code recognizes only EIFS with drainage, required on every wall that is not concrete or masonry: a water-resistive barrier between the foam and the sheathing, at least 90 percent drainage efficiency on the ASTM E2273 test, and a bottom edge at least 6 inches above the ground (2023 ORSC R703.9.1).

No published survey counts how many Portland-area houses have stucco or EIFS, or which kind; the Census Bureau’s survey of new houses reports wall materials only for the country and four regions, with no EIFS category (Census). Only a look behind the finish settles it for a given house.

What taking stucco off involves

Removing stucco is demolition. The plaster breaks off in pieces, the lath under it, nailed or stapled no more than 7 inches apart along the framing (R703.7.1), comes off with it, then the building paper and, at the base of the wall, the weep screed. Stucco is mostly sand by volume (Table R702.1(3)), and OSHA counts sand, concrete and mortar among the materials whose dust contains crystalline silica, so the crew’s dust control matters (OSHA).

With the wall open, five things decide the rest of the job:

  1. The sheathing. Water that got behind stucco or EIFS shows up as soft or stained sheathing. BSC and HUD point to where to look first: below windows and doors, around penetrations, and where a roof meets a wall. A good quote prices its repair per sheet or per hour, because nobody knows the amount in advance.
  2. Bracing. Oregon’s code lists portland cement plaster as one of its wall-bracing methods (Table R602.10.4). If the stucco was doing that job, the wall needs another bracing method, such as structural sheathing, before siding goes on. Ask the contractor, and the building department where structure is involved, whether that part needs a permit.
  3. Windows and doors. Their flashing has to be rebuilt into the new water-resistive barrier, following the window maker’s instructions or with sill pan flashing and protection at the head and sides (R703.4.1). Ask how the trim, sills and jambs will meet the new wall, whose thickness is set by the siding and its drainage space rather than by the old plaster.
  4. The base of the wall. Code stucco’s weep screed may sit as little as 4 inches above soil or 2 inches above paving (R703.7.2.1), while James Hardie and LP both want their siding 6 inches above the ground. The bottom of the new wall may have to start higher, or the soil, mulch or paving come down.
  5. Where stucco stays. On a partial re-side, LP’s instructions keep its siding from touching stucco and call for a 3/8-inch gap with sealant where the two meet.

Patching what stays is plaster work; if part of the house keeps its stucco, ask who finishes those edges.

Before anything comes off: asbestos and lead

Oregon DEQ requires an accredited inspector’s asbestos survey before any residential building built before January 1, 2004 is renovated or demolished, and its owner-occupant exception covers only work inside the home (DEQ). The survey covers what the job will disturb. DEQ’s examples of asbestos materials name cement siding and say nothing about stucco, so it is the inspector who decides what to sample. The asbestos siding guide explains the survey, the lab work and the removal rules.

Paint is the second check. Oregon’s lead rules presume homes built before 1978 have lead paint unless testing shows otherwise (CCB), and painted stucco is painted surface like any other. Disturbing 20 square feet or more of exterior paint on such a house takes a contractor with the CCB’s lead-based paint renovation license and lead-safe methods (Oregon Health Authority).

What the new wall needs under Oregon’s code

Once the stucco is off, the wall is built like any other Oregon re-side. The code asks for a continuous water-resistive barrier behind the siding (R703.2); at least 1/8 inch of drainage space between barrier and siding, made with furring strips, a drainage mat or drainage board, with listed exceptions (R703.1.1); and flashing at every window and door, with kick-out flashing where a lower roof meets a wall (R703.4). The siding replacement page walks through those layers and the order they go on in, and water behind siding shows what happens when one is missing.

Going back to stucco instead is still allowed, but in Multnomah, Washington and Clackamas counties the code asks for more behind it: over wood sheathing, an added drainage space or drainage material at least 3/16 inch deep, or a drainage path that tests at 90 percent efficiency (R703.7.3.1.1).

Can you put siding over stucco?

Sometimes, and the new siding’s maker decides. LP says SmartSide must not touch stucco and may go only over wood or wood-composite siding; James Hardie’s panel instructions call for braced studs or 7/16-inch OSB; and the Vinyl Siding Institute’s manual calls for furring, or removing the old cladding, where a wall is not flat. The larger cost of covering stucco is what stays behind it: old paper, old window flashing and any hidden rot. That is why a Portland re-side usually starts with a tear-off.

Permits and local rules

Portland Permitting & Development lists replacing or repairing siding that is not required to be fire-resistant among work that needs no building permit, and reminds owners that exempt work must still meet the building and zoning codes (PP&D). The list does not mention stucco. Two things can bring a permit in: a wall less than 3 feet from a property line, which has to be fire-resistance rated (BCG-23-10), and structural work behind the stucco, such as replacing bracing. Ask the contractor, or PP&D, before the stucco comes off.

Design rules can decide the material:

  • Portland districts. The City reviews any replacement of an exterior material in a City Historic District, even like for like (City of Portland). Conservation District projects can skip review by meeting design standards, but those require altered finishes to look like the ones already on the house and rule out plywood and composite panels (Chapter 33.218); a stucco-to-siding change therefore normally goes to review. The Portland permits and districts page shows how to check an address.
  • Sherwood. Within the Smockville section of the Old Town Overlay, the residential standards allow stucco only as foundation cladding or a secondary detail, such as a gable end, and prohibit stucco-clad foam such as EIFS. The permitted sidings are horizontal wood siding up to 8 inches to the weather, where concrete or wood-based boards are acceptable, wood shingles, painted board-and-batten in wood, and brick (Sherwood code 16.162.090; the Sherwood page has the full list).
  • Villebois, in Wilsonville. Its Village Zone permits cementitious stucco with a smooth sand finish, along with cedar and fiber cement, and allows a change of material only at a horizontal line or an inside corner, so a partial re-side has to switch there (Wilsonville code 4.125, Table V-3). The Wilsonville page has the city’s other material rules.

Keeping the stucco look

James Hardie and LP both make a stucco-textured panel. Hardie’s panel siding comes in a stucco texture, in sheets 4 feet wide and 8 to 10 feet long, 5/16 inch thick (James Hardie), installed under the same HZ10 rules as any Hardie panel: vertical joints butted, caulked, battened or H-molded, a Z-flashing at each horizontal joint with its 1/4-inch gap left uncaulked, and no panel across a floor line. LP’s Pebbled Stucco panel is 3/8 inch thick in 4-by-9 and 4-by-10 sheets, and its panel instructions advise against furring strips behind it but allow an entangled drainage mat.

Either way the wall is siding, not plaster, with panel joints a stucco wall does not have; fiber cement’s own trade-offs are set out on the fiber cement siding page.

Re-cladding in EIFS is a separate path, and on a wood-frame wall the code calls for the drainage type.

What replacing stucco with siding costs

This site has no dated, sourced figure for removing stucco or EIFS, so it publishes none. The tear-off range on its siding cost page, $70 to $200 per 100 square feet of wall (HomeGuide, national), is for siding, and plaster on lath is a different job.

The new wall is priced like any re-side, by the area of wall rather than the floor area of the house. Angi’s Portland guide prices installed fiber cement at $9 to $16 per square foot of wall, checked September 27, 2026; HomeGuide’s national guide puts engineered wood such as LP SmartSide at $7 to $12 and cedar at $6 to $16 per square foot, and Fixr’s national guide puts vinyl at $3 to $12.

Those ranges leave out most of what makes a stucco job different, so ask every contractor to price these separately:

  1. removal and disposal of the stucco or EIFS, lath and paper;
  2. the asbestos survey and lab fees on a house built before 2004, and lead-safe work on one built before 1978;
  3. sheathing repair, per sheet or per hour, and any new bracing;
  4. window and door flashing, trim, sills and extension jambs;
  5. the base of the wall: weep screed removal, regrading or a new starter detail;
  6. any edge where stucco stays, and who patches it.

With those lines in every quote, two bids can be compared on the same scope.

Start My Siding Quote

No cost and no obligation. Tell us about the house and the siding problem to get started.

Questions, answered

Common questions

Can you put siding over stucco?

Sometimes, but the new siding's maker decides, not the stucco. LP's instructions say its SmartSide must not touch stucco and allow it over existing wood or wood-composite siding only, and every maker's nails have to reach the framing or sheathing its instructions name, through the stucco and lath. Covering stucco also hides whatever is wrong behind it and leaves the old paper and window flashing in place, which is why the stucco usually comes off on a Portland re-side.

Can I install Hardie board siding over stucco?

James Hardie's panel instructions call for braced studs at 24 inches or less, or 7/16-inch OSB sheathing, and send installers to a technical bulletin for layers that will not hold a nail; the examples they give are gypsum and foam. If a contractor proposes Hardie over existing stucco, ask for the James Hardie document that covers the method, because both Hardie's warranty and Oregon's code rely on the maker's written instructions.

How hard is it to remove stucco from a house?

It is demolition work. Code-built stucco on a wood-frame house is three coats of cement plaster, at least 7/8 inch thick over wire lath, with the lath nailed no more than 7 inches apart along the framing and building paper behind it. It comes off in pieces, the lath and nails come out with it, and breaking cement and sand makes the fine dust OSHA regulates as crystalline silica. Windows, doors and the base of the wall then need new flashing and trim.

Are stucco and siding the same?

No. Stucco is cement plaster applied wet over lath and cured into one hard skin; siding is boards or panels fastened to the wall. EIFS, sometimes called synthetic stucco, is a third thing: foam insulation board under a thin reinforced coating and a textured finish. Oregon's code wants a water-resistive barrier and flashing behind all three, but they handle water differently.

How much does it cost to replace stucco with siding?

This site has no dated, sourced figure for removing stucco or EIFS, so it publishes none; the tear-off range on its cost page is for siding. The new siding is priced like any re-side, by wall area; Angi's Portland guide prices installed fiber cement at $9 to $16 per square foot of wall. Ask for removal and disposal, any asbestos survey, sheathing or bracing repair, and window and trim work as separate lines.

What should replace stucco siding?

Any siding the code and the address allow, installed over a new water-resistive barrier, a drainage space and new flashing: fiber cement, engineered wood, cedar or vinyl. Fiber cement panel with a stucco texture keeps the look. Check local rules first: in Sherwood's Old Town, the design standards limit stucco and list the sidings allowed instead, and Portland's historic and conservation districts review a change of material.

A free siding quote request

Start My Siding Quote

No cost and no obligation. Tell us about the house and the siding problem to get started.

No cost to submit a request, and no obligation.